Ingredients for Success Tool
↓ Download as PDFA printable version of this tool to take into the field.
Monocultures (ecological or social) are fragile. A single crop fails in a bad season. A single income source collapses when markets shift. A single decision-making voice misses what others would have caught. Diversity, by contrast, provides options: if one crop fails, another succeeds; if one livelihood is disrupted, another absorbs the shock; if one perspective is wrong, another corrects it. In restoration, social and ecological diversity reinforce each other. A more diverse ecosystem provides more livelihood options. More diverse livelihoods reduce the pressure on any single ecosystem resource. And a community with diverse knowledge, skills, and connections is better equipped to manage a complex ecosystem over time.
Recognize It
-
Does the community's farming, fishing, or resource use draw on multiple species, methods, or income sources?
Diversification that already exists (even informally, even at small scale) is a foundation to build on. Home gardens alongside field crops, multiple fish species targeted by different methods, cottage industries that process farm and forest products: each of these represents an existing buffer against the failure of any single source.
-
Does the local ecosystem support a variety of species and ecological relationships?
Ecological diversity is both a goal and a mechanism. Diverse ecosystems are more stable, more self-regulating, and more resilient to disruption than simplified ones. Signs of existing diversity (multiple plant species, visible predator populations, varied habitat types) indicate that the ecosystem retains functional complexity worth protecting and building on.
-
Does community decision-making draw on a range of voices and perspectives?
Social diversity in governance (women alongside men, younger alongside older, different livelihood groups represented) tends to produce better decisions and broader buy-in than governance that reflects only a narrow set of perspectives. Ask: whose knowledge and whose interests are currently included in how the community makes decisions, and whose are missing?
-
Has the community developed connections beyond its own boundaries: to other communities, to outside organizations, to markets or institutions?
Social diversity isn't only internal. Communities that have developed connections to the wider world (through outside partnerships, market relationships, peer networks, or institutional ties) have access to a broader range of options and resources when local conditions change. Apo Island's dialogue with Silliman University scientists diversified the community's awareness of what was possible before any physical restoration began.
-
Are livelihoods distributed across enough different activities that the failure of one doesn't threaten the whole community?
The test of livelihood diversity is resilience under stress: if the fishery has a bad year, do families have other income? If crop prices fall, does the community have other ways to meet its needs? Diversification that exists only on paper (or that everyone engages in identically) provides less protection than genuine variety across households and activities.
Amplify It
If diversity is already present in the community or ecosystem, these strategies deepen and extend it.
Expand livelihood diversity deliberately alongside ecological restoration
As restoration proceeds and ecosystem health improves, new livelihood opportunities often emerge: tourism, new products, processing enterprises, training and hosting roles for other communities. Planning for these opportunities rather than letting them develop accidentally ensures that the economic benefits of restoration are distributed broadly and that the community's livelihood base grows alongside its ecological base.
Protect and expand the variety of species and habitats in the ecosystem
Ecological diversity is self-reinforcing up to a point (more species support more species), but it requires protection to get there. Ensuring that restoration doesn't create new monocultures (even ecologically beneficial ones) and that habitat variety is maintained or expanded gives the ecosystem more pathways for recovery and more resistance to future disruption.
Actively include underrepresented voices in governance
Diversity in decision-making doesn't happen automatically; it requires deliberate inclusion of people whose perspectives are typically absent or marginalized. Women's groups, youth, community members from different livelihood backgrounds, people with experience in other places: each brings knowledge and interests that improve the quality of collective decisions. Building structures that make this inclusion normal rather than exceptional is the goal.
Use outside connections to expand the community's awareness of options
One of the highest-value forms of social diversity is exposure to how other communities have addressed similar problems: what approaches exist, what has worked elsewhere, what's possible that the community doesn't yet know about. Outside partnerships, peer exchanges, and visits to other sites all diversify the community's sense of what's available to it.
Build redundancy into critical systems
Diversity as insurance means having backup options for the things that matter most. Multiple water sources in case one fails. Multiple governance mechanisms in case one is captured or undermined. Multiple market channels in case one closes. Deliberate redundancy (especially in systems the community depends on most) is a practical expression of the diversity principle.
Build It
If diversity is limited (ecologically, economically, or socially), these strategies help establish it.
Start diversification where risk is lowest
Asking families to diversify livelihoods when they're financially precarious asks them to take on risk they may not be able to absorb. Starting with diversification that requires minimal upfront investment: home gardens, small-scale processing of existing products, cottage industries that use available materials, builds a foundation without requiring a bet the community can't afford to lose.
Use the restoration itself as a platform for livelihood diversification
Restoration activities often create livelihood opportunities directly: hosting visitors, training other communities, producing and selling seedlings or compost, managing ecotourism. Building these opportunities into the restoration design from the beginning means that economic diversity grows alongside ecological recovery, not as an afterthought.
Introduce ecological diversity through the choice of restoration species and methods
Where degradation has simplified the ecosystem, restoration design can rebuild variety deliberately: by choosing polyculture over monoculture, by reintroducing multiple native species rather than a single dominant one, by restoring varied habitat types rather than a single preferred condition. Each additional species or habitat type is an additional ecological function and an additional option for the future.
Develop the community's connections to outside networks and knowledge
Social diversity is partly internal (more voices, more perspectives) and partly relational: more connections to the world beyond the community. Facilitating these connections to peer communities, to outside organizations, to markets and institutions that can provide options the community doesn't currently have access to, builds the external dimension of social diversity.
Work Around It
When the community's livelihoods are locked into a single system by debt or dependency
Diversification requires some degree of freedom to experiment, which debt and dependency can eliminate. Where families are locked into purchasing and selling relationships that constrain their options (through debt to input suppliers, through contract farming arrangements, through dependence on a single buyer) addressing those dependencies directly may be a prerequisite for meaningful diversification. Collective action, as Punukula demonstrated, can sometimes break these dependencies where individual action cannot.
When the ecosystem has been so simplified that ecological diversity is very low
Severely degraded ecosystems may need active intervention to reintroduce diversity: replanting multiple native species, managing for habitat variety, reintroducing species that have been locally eliminated. This is slower and more resource-intensive than working with existing diversity, but it creates the ecological foundation that natural recovery processes need to build on.
When governance consistently excludes key voices
If women, young people, or specific livelihood groups are systematically excluded from community decision-making, formal inclusion mechanisms alone rarely fix the problem. Building parallel spaces where underrepresented groups can develop their own collective voice: women's cooperatives, youth groups, livelihood associations, creates constituencies that eventually change who gets heard in broader governance.
Learn More
Learn about systems thinking and how social and ecological diversity creates resilience and expands options.